Midnight Mayhem
Similar games

Games like Midnight Mayhem

Midnight Mayhem from 3,02 € (3,61 € with fees)

Steam Key · Kinguin · coupon NOVGOC10

Move the slider and decide how alike they need to be: from near-identical to a loose family resemblance. We show you what they share and what each one costs today across 45 stores.

Games similar to Midnight Mayhem

Platform 0 games
50% Genuinely similar: they share what matters

All of them count for the search. Tap one to cross it out and leave it out; tap again to bring it back.

No payment fees With payment fees

Final prices with fees

Carnival Hunt
Carnival Hunt
€9.91
€7.74 -61% Steam Key
GCDKGamivo-25%Copied! Save €12 vs Steam View dealGamivo
See offers at 17 more storesSee 17 stores →
Gehinnom
Gehinnom
€7.45
€6.79 -17% Steam Key
NOVGOC10-10%Copied! Save €1 vs Steam View dealKinguin
See offers at 2 more storesSee 2 stores →
Storebound
Storebound
€1.03
€0.97 -88% Steam Key
NOVGOC10-10%Copied! Save €7 vs Steam View dealKinguin
See offers at 16 more storesSee 16 stores →
Escape from Playtime
Escape from Playtime
€7.84
€7.14 -29% Steam Key
NOVGOC10-10%Copied! Save €3 vs Steam View dealKinguin
See offers at 9 more storesSee 9 stores →
Little Nightmares 3
Little Nightmares 3
€16.26
€14.19 -65% Steam Key
GCDK14DEAL-14%Copied! Save €26 vs Steam View dealK4G
See offers at 20 more storesSee 20 stores →
Phobos
Phobos
€0.62
€0.58 -94% Steam Key
SEAL17CKD-17%Copied! Save €10 vs Steam View dealGameseal
See offers at 5 more storesSee 5 stores →
Echo Mates
Echo Mates
€3.97
€3.63 -63% Steam Key
NOVGOC10-10%Copied! Save €6 vs Steam View dealKinguin
See offers at 3 more storesSee 3 stores →
Dig, Dig, Die
Dig, Dig, Die
€3.83
€3.24 -59% Steam Key
Gocdkeys-16%Copied! Save €5 vs Steam View dealDifmark Digital Keys
See offers at 10 more storesSee 10 stores →
Dark Hours
Dark Hours
€9.20
€7.36 -26% Steam Key
GCDKGamivo-23%Copied! Save €3 vs Steam View dealGamivo
See offers at 12 more storesSee 12 stores →
The Blackout Club
The Blackout Club
€4.58
€3.65 -87% Steam Key
GCDKGamivo-25%Copied! Save €25 vs Steam View dealGamivo
See offers at 10 more storesSee 10 stores →
Evil Corporation
Evil Corporation
€1.63
€1.51 -85% Steam Key
NOVGOC10-10%Copied! Save €8 vs Steam View dealKinguin
See offers at 2 more storesSee 2 stores →
Dread Hunger
Dread Hunger
€28.01
€23.69 Steam Account
Gocdkeys-16%Copied! View dealDifmark
See offers at 1 more storeSee 1 store →
Machine Party
Machine Party
€7.69
€5.25 -30% Steam Key
GCKG2AB2J8X-33%Copied! Save €2 vs Steam View dealG2A
See offers at 12 more storesSee 12 stores →
Altarium
Altarium
€1.91
€1.76 -82% Steam Key
NOVGOC10-10%Copied! Save €8 vs Steam View dealKinguin
See offers at 3 more storesSee 3 stores →
The Outlast Trials
The Outlast Trials
€11.47
€10.40 -73% Steam Key
GOCDKEYS10-10%Copied! Save €29 vs Steam View dealDriffle
See offers at 18 more storesSee 18 stores →
Mimic Busters
Mimic Busters
€1.47
€1.33 -83% Steam Key
GCDK14DEAL-14%Copied! Save €6 vs Steam View dealK4G
See offers at 5 more storesSee 5 stores →
Dreadline: Net Quota
Dreadline: Net Quota
€2.13
€1.96 -54% Steam Key
NOVGOC10-10%Copied! Save €2 vs Steam View dealKinguin
See offers at 4 more storesSee 4 stores →
Unholy
Unholy
€9.02
€7.69 -74% Steam Key
GCDKGamivo-17%Copied! Save €22 vs Steam View dealGamivo
See offers at 13 more storesSee 13 stores →
Totally Safe Moon Project
Totally Safe Moon Project
€2.10
€1.94 -57% Steam Key
NOVGOC10-10%Copied! Save €3 vs Steam View dealKinguin
See offers at 7 more storesSee 7 stores →
Amnesia: The Dark Descent
Amnesia: The Dark Descent
€5.23
€4.29 -78% Steam Key
GCKG2AB2J8X-19%Copied! Save €15 vs Steam View dealG2A
See offers at 12 more storesSee 12 stores →
Dread Flats
Dread Flats
€4.31
€3.96 -33% Steam Key
Gocdkeys10-10%Copied! Save €2 vs Steam View dealEneba
See offers at 1 more storeSee 1 store →
Macabre
Macabre
€5.47
€4.66 -52% Steam Key
SEAL17CKD-17%Copied! Save €5 vs Steam View dealGameseal
See offers at 7 more storesSee 7 stores →
Dumb Ways to Build
Dumb Ways to Build
€6.24
€5.69 -29% Steam Key
NOVGOC10-10%Copied! Save €2 vs Steam View dealKinguin
See offers at 5 more storesSee 5 stores →
Mimic
Mimic
€1.31
€1.22 -89% Steam Key
NOVGOC10-10%Copied! Save €10 vs Steam View dealKinguin
See offers at 3 more storesSee 3 stores →
Hektor
Hektor
€3.25
€2.98 -70% Steam Key
NOVGOC10-10%Copied! Save €7 vs Steam View dealKinguin
See offers at 5 more storesSee 5 stores →
PANICORE
PANICORE
€6.54
€5.98 -40% Steam Key
Gocdkeys10-10%Copied! Save €4 vs Steam View dealEneba
See offers at 10 more storesSee 10 stores →
Stream Train
Stream Train
€7.77
€7.08 -11% Steam Key
NOVGOC10-10%Copied! Save €1 vs Steam View dealKinguin
See offers at 3 more storesSee 3 stores →
Outlast 2
Outlast 2
€3.42
€2.89 -85% Steam Key
Gocdkeys-16%Copied! Save €17 vs Steam View dealDifmark Digital Keys
See offers at 15 more storesSee 15 stores →
Astrumis Survive Together
Astrumis Survive Together
€4.71
€4.30 -56% Steam Key
NOVGOC10-10%Copied! Save €5 vs Steam View dealKinguin
See offers at 3 more storesSee 3 stores →
Anaria: Reborn
Anaria: Reborn
€1.29
€1.20 -83% Steam Key
NOVGOC10-10%Copied! Save €6 vs Steam View dealKinguin
See offers at 2 more storesSee 2 stores →
Finals Week
Finals Week
€4.74
€4.33 -13% Steam Key
NOVGOC10-10%Copied! Save €1 vs Steam View dealKinguin
See offers at 7 more storesSee 7 stores →
Separated
Separated
€8.29
€7.01 -30% Steam Key
Gocdkeys-16%Copied! Save €3 vs Steam View dealDifmark Digital Keys
See offers at 3 more storesSee 3 stores →
Nothing is that close. Move the slider down and games with less in common will show up — that's usually where the hidden gems are.
Games like the ones on your Steam wishlist Sign in and we'll tell you which games are most like the ones on your Steam wishlist and the ones you follow.

How we measure which games are like Midnight Mayhem

Not every tag is worth the same. The ones thousands of games share ("singleplayer", "action") say very little about a game; the ones that define its character ("Souls-like", "dark fantasy") say almost everything. Our calculation takes that into account, and how many tags each game has too, so a game with lots of tags doesn't end up looking like everything.

LevelWhat you find
90-100%Near-identical: same subgenre, same tone, same mechanics
70-85%Very close: you will like it for the same reasons
50-65%Similar: shares what matters, different packaging
30-45%A family resemblance: this is where the surprises are
10-25%Surprise me: just one thing in common

Every card tells you what they have in common, so you can judge whether the resemblance is the one you were after. And the price is the lowest verified today across 45 stores.

FAQ about games like Midnight Mayhem

What game is most like Midnight Mayhem?

Today it is Carnival Hunt. It shares the most of what makes Midnight Mayhem special, not the most tags overall: they have Stealth, Dark, Psychological Horror in common.

Are there cheap games like Midnight Mayhem?

Yes. Right now the cheapest one on this list is Phobos, at €0.17 (Key). Move the slider down and more will appear: bargains are often among the lesser-known games.

Are there games similar to Midnight Mayhem on PS5?

Tap PS5 and the list only keeps games with a PS5 version. Right now: 13, and the closest is Forest Escape: Last Train.

Why does a game with several identical tags come out with a low resemblance?

Because matching on generic tags is not the same as being alike. Thousands of games share "singleplayer" and "action" with each other; what counts is matching on what makes each one special.