The best detective games on PS4: L.A. Noire, The Wolf Among Us and 9 more

0 replies · 37 views

Best price for Murdered: Soul Suspect (PS4)

16,46€(17,39€ with fees)PSN Card·Driffle

0°
GocdkeysLV 10Staff
The best detective games on PS4: L.A. Noire, The Wolf Among Us and 9 more

GOCDKEYS TeamUpdated 10 min read

11 detective games for PS4 with today's prices. Sherlock Holmes Chapter One is €4.49 (no fees) as a PSN Key, Judgment €9.99 (no fees), L.A. Noire €19.99.

Key facts

Cheapest right now
€8.77 Standard · Account · Global · Difmark
Live offers
3 offers · 3 stores
Our pick
Standard · PSN Key · Global · Playstation Store — €19.99
See all offers for Murdered: Soul Suspect

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One costs €4.49 (no fees) as a PSN Key on the PlayStation Store this morning, and Judgment and AI: The Somnium Files – nirvanA Initiative are both €9.99 (no fees). Those are the three cheap ones. The other eight detective games on this list are full price on PS4 today, and for several of them we've seen the PSN Key at a third of what it costs now.

How we picked them: we took the PS4 games in our catalogue whose PC version has Steam's Detective tag and at least two offers in stock, then dropped the ones where the investigating is a side activity. Batman: Arkham Knight has a detective mode, but it's an action game; Home Sweet Home and Saturnalia are horror; We Were Here Forever is a co-op puzzle game. The review percentages are from Steam users and refer to the PC version, because there's no public player score for PS4 games we can quote.

On eight of the eleven, the cheapest offer is a Difmark account. That means paying for the login to someone else's PSN account that already owns the game. It plays on your PS4, but the game stays in that person's name, and if the seller takes the account back you lose it. We'd buy the PSN Key, which goes on your own account, or a disc. Difmark prices below already include the Gocdkeys coupon (16%); the PlayStation Store and Amazon don't charge fees.

Crime fiction classics: L.A. Noire, Blacksad and The Wolf Among Us

L.A. Noire puts you in Cole Phelps's shoes as he climbs the ranks of the LAPD in post-war Los Angeles, from traffic to homicide and vice. You walk crime scenes looking for clues, then sit suspects down and watch their faces to decide whether they're lying, and if you accuse the wrong one the case goes on anyway. 85% of 31,440 Steam reviews are positive. The L.A. Noire PS4 key is €19.99 (no fees) on the PlayStation Store. The Difmark account is just €2.13 (€2.23 with fees), and we understand the temptation, but at that price you're renting someone else's copy.

Blacksad: Under the Skin comes from the Spanish comics by Juan Díaz Canales and Juanjo Guarnido: John Blacksad is a cat private eye in New York in the fifties, and the city is full of animals in hats. It plays like a narrative adventure, with dialogue choices and a deduction screen where you join clues together. 83% of 5,425 positive on Steam. The PSN Key costs €24.99 (no fees), but the disc is cheaper at Amazon ES, €15.90 (no fees). Account: €8.39 (€8.77 with fees).

The Wolf Among Us is Telltale's game based on the Fables comics. Bigby Wolf, the Big Bad Wolf himself, is the sheriff of a hidden community of fairy-tale characters living in New York, and a murder in the first episode sets the rest off. Your choices in conversations and fights change who trusts you. It's one of the two best-rated games here, 97% of 32,669 on Steam. PSN Key €14.99 (no fees); account €6.29 (€6.57 with fees).

Two Sherlock Holmes games, very different prices

Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments gives you six separate cases. You gather clues, connect them into deductions inside Holmes's head and then pick a culprit, and nothing stops you from accusing the wrong person. At the end of each case you also decide whether to condemn or let them go. 89% of 7,198 positive on Steam. The PSN Key is €39.99 (no fees), which is a lot for a game this old; the account is €10.07 (€10.52 with fees).

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One goes back to a young Holmes, who travels to a Mediterranean island to find out how his mother died. It's an open world, with disguises and witness questioning across a whole town. Steam users are a bit cooler on this one, 77% of 4,266 positive. It's also the cheapest game on the list: €4.49 (no fees) for the PSN Key, the same as its lowest price we've recorded on the PlayStation Store. Difmark's account costs more than that, so there's no reason to look elsewhere.

Ace Attorney: crime scenes and courtrooms

Ace Attorney Investigations Collection swaps Phoenix Wright for the prosecutor Miles Edgeworth and moves the action out of court: you walk around crime scenes, pick up evidence and catch witnesses in contradictions on the spot. The collection has two games, and the second had never been released officially in English before. 96% of 3,527 positive on Steam. The PSN Key is €39.99 (no fees), but the disc costs €24.10 (no fees) at Amazon UK and €25.29 (no fees) at Amazon FR. The account is €16.79 (€17.55 with fees). These are its live offers:

Promoted store
Coupon
Gocdkeys -16% copy Copied!
€19.99 €17.55
Store Difmark
Global Icon
Region Global
Account
Product type Account
Standard
Edition Standard
Description Icon
Fees +€0.76

The Great Ace Attorney Chronicles is also two games, set at the end of the 19th century between Japan and London. Ryunosuke Naruhodo is a student who ends up defending himself in court and becomes a lawyer, with Herlock Sholmes turning up at the worst moments. 93% of 5,167 positive. The PSN Key is €39.99 (no fees); we saw it at €15.99 on 10 and 11 September and again from 22 to 26 October. The account costs €10.99 (€11.48 with fees).

When the detective is already dead

Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective is by Shu Takumi, who created Ace Attorney. Sissel wakes up dead, with no memory, and has one night to find out who killed him. As a ghost he can jump between objects and move them, and he can go back four minutes before someone else's death to try to stop it. Along with The Wolf Among Us, it's the best-rated game here: 97% of 6,602 on Steam. Today the PSN Key costs €29.99 (no fees), when it was €9.89 on 10 September and again on 22 and 23 October. Account: €6.85 (€7.16 with fees).

Murdered: Soul Suspect starts with detective Ronan O'Connor being killed in Salem. As a ghost he walks through walls, possesses the living to read their thoughts and investigates his own murder. 87% of 12,134 Steam reviews are positive. PSN Key: €19.99 (no fees). Account: €8.39 (€8.77 with fees).

Japanese thrillers: Judgment and AI: The Somnium Files

Judgment is by the studio behind the Yakuza games and takes place on the same streets of Kamurocho. Takayuki Yagami was a lawyer until a case went wrong; now he's a private detective chasing a serial killer. You tail suspects, search scenes and pick locks, and there are plenty of street fights too. 93% of 9,572 Steam reviews are positive. The PSN Key is €9.99 (no fees), the lowest we've recorded for it on the PlayStation Store, and the disc at Amazon FR costs almost twice that, €17.96 (no fees).

AI: The Somnium Files – nirvanA Initiative is a sequel: two special agents and their AI partners investigate a serial killer who leaves victims cut in half. The investigation happens partly in the dreams of witnesses, which you explore against the clock. It helps to have played the first game. 85% of 3,621 positive on Steam. €9.99 (no fees) for the PSN Key, the lowest we've seen; the Difmark account costs more.

Buy now or set an alert?

Lowest PSN Key prices we've recorded on the PlayStation Store, without fees, for the four that cost much more today:

  • Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective: €9.89 (10 September and 22-23 October), €29.99 today.
  • Blacksad: Under the Skin: €4.99 (29-31 August and 11-25 September), €24.99 today.
  • The Great Ace Attorney Chronicles: €15.99 (10-11 September and 22-26 October), €39.99 today.
  • Ace Attorney Investigations Collection: €23.99 (10 September), €39.99 today.

For those four, a price alert for Ghost Trick (or for any of the others) makes more sense than buying today: you pick a price and we email you when it gets there. Sherlock Holmes Chapter One, Judgment and nirvanA Initiative are already at their lowest. If you also play on the newer console, we have the best detective games on PS5, and there's an Xbox list too.

Prices checked on the morning of 18 November.

More posts

What do you think? Share your take on this post below with other players.

0 replies

No replies yet. Be the first.

Your reply

Log in to join the conversation and earn tickets.